There are a lot of books out there about adoption, and it’s been a struggle thus far to separate the wheat from the chaff. In the interest of providing utility to other couples who may be going down the adoption road as well, here’s the first in what may become a series of book reviews.
The Complete Adoption Book
Laura Beauvais-Godwin and Raymond Godwin
This was the first book I read, and still probably the most useful out of all of them. It did an excellent job of detailing all of the different decisions that have to be made in the adoption process (domestic vs international, private vs agency, open vs closed, etc, etc), and discussed the issues involved in each type of adoption. As far as educating oneself with the facts and the details of adoption, this was by far the best resource that I’ve seen so far.
My main complaint would be that I kept waiting for a summary – a chart showing side-by-side comparisions of the different adoption types, or some resource like that that would help me make my decision. Instead, the book steers far clear of offering any sort of recommendation, and sticks to purely factual descriptions. I understand and respect that approach, but I would have liked at least a little help to point me in the right direction.
It was also very much a fact book, and while one can’t talk about adoption without talking about emotions, it had a limited amount of storytelling and anecdotes. I enjoyed the fact based approach, whereas I don’t think Betsy liked this book as much.
Bottom line: Excellent fact resource, but light on the “warm fuzzies” and frustrating if you are looking for steering in your decision making.
A Love Like No Other
Edited by Pamela Kruger and Jill Smolowe
This book was a collection of stories from different adoptive parents, running the range of almost every adoption type. This was a little light on raw “facts”, but it did an excellent job of showing the wide range of experiences people had.
Okay, before I go any further: I really enjoyed this book, and if friends and/or family wanted to do some reading to learn about the type of experiences Betsy and I will be facing, this is the book I would recommend. It was very good.
That being said… I had a couple of major beefs with it. The first issue is what I’ve started referring to as AHDS, or Apathetic Heterosexual Dad Syndrome (or Stereotype). In the reading I’ve done thus far, be it in books, websites, magazines, etc, the only men that get portrayed in a positive light are the gay couples looking to adopt. They are usually full of energy and excitement about starting a family. The men in heterosexual couples? Well, they were dragged into this adoption thing against their better judgement, and really, they’d rather be off fishing somewhere than holding their child for the first time. Changing a diaper? Isn’t that why Mr. AHD got married in the first place, so he didn’t have to do stuff like that? The good news about AHDS is that it motivated me to start this blog to help fill the void, but still – rather annoying.
I’ll save the other beef for the next book, as both suffered the same problem and I don’t want to sound overly critical of what was otherwise an excellent book.
Bottom line: Betsy says it was excellent; I wouldn’t know, because reading is women’s work. I was too busy watching football and belching.
.
The Family of Adoption
Joyce Maguire Pavao
I’d recommend this book for families that already have completed the adoption process. The book is written with a heavy clinical psychiatric viewpoint, charting the growth of an adopted child from infancy through early adulthood, and discussing potential emotional and developmental impacts to be aware of. The points are illustrated with interesting and enlightening anecdotes from the author’s practice as a therapist specializing in adoptive families. For a couple just starting the adoption process, it was not really aimed at us, but the information contained will be useful to refer back to once we complete the process and begin parenting.
And it will be important to have a book to refer back to, because all adoptive children are crazy and liable to burn your house down with (or without) the slightest provocation. At least, that’s what it started to feel like after reading the last couple of books. To be fair, both The Family Of Adoption and A Love Like No Other do try to present some positive stories, and if The Family is going to try to prepare you for the challenges in parenting, it’s going to have to focus on the more difficult aspects. But reading those two books back to back was pretty intimidating, with heart-breaking stories of learning disabilities and behavioral disorders. I had to keep reminding myself that the potential for those issues is there with any child, and to remind myself of the adults I know who were adopted and who haven’t had these issues.
Bottom line: Good resource for parents of adopted children who aren’t easily scared; maybe less so for a first-time adoptive couple.
Yes, You Can Adopt!
Richard Mintzer
Yes, you can be a boring book that thinly disguises your distaste for certain adoption paths (including the one that Betsy and I had pretty much already decided on by the time I read this book)!
Bottom line: See above.
.
.
The Kid
Dan Savage
And finally… The Kid.
Probably the first thing you should know is who Dan Savage is – he’s a (very) openly gay sex-advice columnist who writes a column filled with quite explicit advice mixed with a heavily liberal political slant. And he doesn’t pull any punches in this book.
I know that the vast majority (all?) of my family would not be comfortable reading this book, and that many of my friends would fall in the same category. That being said, this is the first (and thus far, only) book I’ve found that follows a single couple all the way through the process, from the initial meetings with the agency until after the child is home. Having a case study of the entire process a couple went through is an excellent resource.
It was also arguably the most influential book in our process so far. Betsy and I are going to be pursuing the same path towards adoption that Dan and Terry did (even the same agency – they are also from Seattle), and while we were already leaning in that direction, I think this book cemented it for us and made us sure of our decision.
Bottom line: Don’t read this book unless you know what you are getting into. If you are comfortable reading it, though, it’s probably the best description of what awaits us – we’ll just have one more X chromosome in our corner.